Good morning. Thanks for starting your day with the Best of the West.
Today's reading time is 5 minutes.
Spotlight: Richard Hooker
Portrait of an unknown man, formerly thought to be Richard Hooker, oil on canvas, 16th c.
Richard Hooker was an English theologian who wrote during the English Reformations. Born in 1554 A.D., Hooker lived during the tumultuous reign of Elizabeth I, and while he is highly revered in Anglican circles, his name does not always find its way into discussions on the development of the Western canon. Nevertheless, his writings are foundational to the understanding of modern English Christianity, law and society, and the common good.
Hooker wrote during a time when the English Church was still grappling with the consequences of Henry VIII’s split with Rome. These religious debates boiled down to two choices: either continue the more radical church reforms seen on the European continent or reverse course and return to pre-Reformation practices. Rather than embrace either supposed extremes, Hooker fought for what later became known as the via media, the middle way.
Although via media was not coined by Hooker himself, the spirit of the middle way is found throughout his work, especially in Of the Laws of Ecclesiastical Polity. Rather than choosing one side of the debate and discarding the other, Hooker sought to preserve what was valuable in each competing viewpoint. He argued that humans encounter truth through Scripture, tradition, and reason working together in harmony. While being a Protestant and believing Scripture remained the supreme authority, reason was not to be discarded since it is a God-given gift that helped interpret truth. Additionally, tradition was a gift passed down from the generations of Christians wrestling with the same questions rather than a heavy yoke. Through this rationale, the middle way was not a compromise to avoid uncomfortable conversations but a path towards a deeper understanding of Christian society.
Hooker contributed not only to religious disputes but also the English understanding of law. He believed that God governs the world through law. Human laws, political institutions, and social customs were not merely instruments of power but means by which communities pursue justice and order as communicated by God. Since human beings are rational creatures, they can discern principles that promote the flourishing of society. This understanding provided the foundation for the English common-law tradition which valued deliberation, custom, and gradual reform over revolution.
In a time where many claimed that every social question could be settled solely through direct appeals to Scripture, Hooker defended the legitimacy of human discernment through laws. It was not necessary for every single social or political question to be explicitly found in the Scriptures. Communities could establish laws and institutions according to reason, experience, and the needs of the commonwealth, provided they remained consistent with Christian principles. This approach gave English society a framework for navigating disagreement without descending into chaos or coercion.
Hooker's legacy can still be seen today. His emphasis on moderation, reasoned debate, and the pursuit of the common good influenced broader English understandings of law and governance. He reminds us that lasting societies are built not on the triumph of one faction over another but on collaboration. The careful integration of truth, reason, tradition, and a shared pursuit of the common good can create a harmonious society.
— Spotlight generously contributed by Tyler Brooks
Verse: Paradiso by Dante (Canto 33)
As I drew nearer to the end of all desire,
I brought my longing's ardor to a final height,
Just as I ought. My vision, becoming pure,
Entered more and more the beam of that high light
That shines on its own truth. From then, my seeing
Became too large for speech, which fails at a sight
Beyond all boundaries, at memory's undoing—
As when the dreamer sees and after the dream
The passion endures, imprinted on his being
Though he can't recall the rest. I am the same:
Inside my heart, although my vision is almost
Entirely faded, droplets of its sweetness come
The way the sun dissolves the snow's crust—
The way, in the wind that stirred the light leaves,
The oracle that the Sibyl wrote was lost.
This brief excerpt from Dante’s triumphant ending to his Divine Comedy includes lines 46-48 and 52-66 of Canto 33 and was translated by Robert Pinsky.
Pensées
Community – According to a recent Pew research poll, only about 1 in 4 Americans know most of their neighbours. 12% said they didn’t know any. This is a wholly modern phenomenon, as in the past, it wasn’t just a social expectation that one would get to know one’s neighbours, it was often a necessity, especially in the newly settled West, where neighbours often had to work together to survive. As Charles Murray notes in Coming Apart, only a few decades ago, ‘urban neighbourhoods [used] to be as close as small towns’ to the point where, ‘residents defined themselves by the neighbourhood in which they grew up.’ Today, things have drastically changed.
Q ~ Do you know your neighbours? What do you think has helped contribute to the disintegration of our communities?
Diversions
Join Tweedy Pubs for a visit to Ye Olde Mitre in London, est’d 1546.
7 masterpieces which were lost but have since been found.
Admire Paul Gauguin’s Landscape at le Pouldu, c. 1890
Watch: 10 reasons to read Anthony Trollope.
Enjoyed this issue?
The Foundations Forum newsletter is your weekly opportunity to reflect on the good, the true, and the beautiful. No news cycle drama. Just the Best of the West in five minutes or less. If you enjoy reading FF with your morning cuppa, help us encourage more people by forwarding this email to a friend.
Forwarded this issue?
Subscribe below for weekly reflections from the Foundations Forum ⬇️